Four years working across private equity-backed businesses have taught me that the biggest procurement savings opportunities are rarely where you'd expect.

Four years working across private equity-backed businesses have taught me that the biggest procurement savings opportunities are rarely where you'd expect.

Author: Tom Kendall

Operating Costs: There's Far More Than Meets the Eye

By Tom Kendall | Procurement Delivery Lead – Indirect Spend | ATP

I've worked in procurement for many years, but the last four years working across multiple private equity-backed businesses have probably taught me more than any other period of my career.

And there's one thing I've come to realise. Every new client is a bit like a scratch card. You never quite know what you're going to uncover until you start scratching away.

That's one of the things I enjoy most about operating cost procurement, also known as indirect procurement, general and administrative expenditure (G&A), or goods not for resale.

No two businesses are the same. No two supplier contracts are the same. And some of the biggest opportunities are found in places you might never think to look.

Sometimes, you have just got to keep drilling

We support a prominent private equity investor across three restaurant chains, collectively operating around 160 restaurants.

Over the course of our work, we've invested hundreds, if not thousands, of hours reviewing dozens of expenditure categories, looking for opportunities to reduce costs and improve operating profitability.

And, of course, not everything produces results. We've explored plenty of rabbit holes, encountered excellent existing supplier arrangements and identified potential opportunities that simply couldn't be pursued because of contractual commitments.

It's a bit like drilling for oil. You can carry out all the research and preparation in the world, but until you start drilling, you don't really know what you'll find.

And sometimes, you strike gold. One of our biggest successes across those restaurants came from an expenditure category that most people would probably overlook.

Linen:

Yes, linen. The washing, ironing and rental of tea towels and chefs' whites.

Through reviewing and restructuring these arrangements, we secured annual savings of more than £250,000.

A quarter of a million pounds. Every year. On linen! And when you consider what an additional £250,000 of recurring annual operating profit could potentially be worth to a private equity investor at exit, the significance becomes even greater.

It's a perfect example of why you have to keep looking. The biggest opportunities aren't necessarily the most obvious.

A parcel isn't just a parcel

Take parcel delivery, another category where we regularly review expenditure running into tens of millions of pounds.

To most people, it's simply a box and a driver. But look a little closer.

What does the parcel weigh? What are its dimensions? How is volumetric weight calculated? Where is it going? When does it need collecting? Does it contain hazardous goods? Is it travelling internationally? Is it oversized?

Should a business use one carrier or several? Could certain deliveries be handled more economically through the postal network?

Then there's the supplier market itself. Who's competitive right now? Who has spare capacity? Who's experiencing service challenges? And who's actively looking to win market share?

A supplier that's difficult to negotiate with today might be far more receptive to new business six months down the line.

What initially appears to be a relatively straightforward purchasing decision quickly becomes something far more complex.

And that's just parcels. Now multiply that complexity across more than 100 different operating cost categories.

Knowing the market is everything

If I had to identify one of the biggest factors behind successful procurement, it would be understanding what's really happening within supplier markets.

I'd argue that as much as 70% of what makes us effective comes down to that knowledge.

Who's performing well? Who's struggling? Who's acquiring whom? Who's investing in capacity? Who's prepared to compete aggressively for new business?

And, just as importantly, who are the people making those decisions?

Through our collective purchasing activity, we often develop relationships with suppliers at a much more senior level than an individual business might ordinarily be able to access.

Those relationships, combined with an understanding of market conditions, can make a significant difference when negotiating commercial arrangements.

Timing is another critical factor. I've seen ocean freight rates fluctuate between $1,600 and $8,000 per container within a single year.

In those circumstances, securing longer-term price certainty at the right moment can be worth considerably more than negotiating another $50 off an individual shipment.

The market doesn't operate around your procurement calendar.

Knowing when to act can be just as important as knowing how to negotiate.

Why even excellent internal procurement teams benefit from specialist support

Over the years, I've worked alongside some outstanding internal procurement teams.

I've also seen businesses generating billions in revenue with just one or two people responsible for managing their entire operating cost base.

The challenge isn't necessarily capability. It's capacity and the sheer breadth of specialist knowledge required.

No individual can realistically maintain detailed, up-to-date expertise across every supplier market and expenditure category.

At GSF Car Parts, for example, we've worked alongside an excellent internal team and identified opportunities representing more than £2.5 million in potential annual operating profit improvement.

Not because the internal team wasn't doing a great job. Quite the opposite. Simply because there's a limit to how much any small team can cover, regardless of how capable or experienced its people may be.

At ATP, we have 12 operating cost specialists, each developing expertise across different procurement categories, sectors and supplier markets.

That collective knowledge allows us to work alongside internal teams, complement their existing capabilities and explore opportunities they may not otherwise have the time or specialist resources to investigate.

And even with that breadth of experience, we're still learning every single day.

Every day is a school day

Artificial intelligence will undoubtedly transform procurement, and it's an area we're investing heavily in ourselves.

Technology will increasingly help us analyse expenditure, identify patterns, assess supplier information and improve the efficiency of procurement processes.

But there are aspects of the job that remain much harder to replicate. The supplier conversations. The relationships built over many years. The understanding of commercial pressures. And the live market intelligence that can make the difference between a good deal and an exceptional one.

For me, successful procurement has always required curiosity. You have to keep asking questions, challenging assumptions and looking beneath the surface.

You also have to accept that you'll never know everything. I could review 20 waste management contracts and encounter 20 completely different situations, each with its own challenges, complexities and opportunities.

That's what keeps the job interesting. Operating cost procurement isn't simply about buying things more cheaply. It's about understanding how businesses operate, identifying opportunities that others might overlook, navigating complex supplier markets and knowing when to act.

And when done well, the financial impact can be substantial. Sometimes, it really can make the difference between profit and loss.

Four years into this fascinating multi-client environment, I'm more convinced than ever that there's far more to operating costs than meets the eye.

And that's exactly why I love what I do.

Tom Kendall
Procurement Delivery Lead – Indirect Spend | ATP